A Twelve-Month Option Can't Buy a Fifteen-Month Audit
Ernst & Young took the Navy, Air Force and agency-wide Pentagon audits inside 28 days on three single quotes, $1.86 billion in all. Two of the three went straight back to the option structure that made the last pair run long.
The description field on HQ042321F0002 reads "FINANCIAL STATEMENT AUDITS FOR FISCAL YEARS 2021-2025."
It is October 2026. The order is still open, and FPDS says it runs to March 31, 2027.
The record is current. Ernst & Young's fourth and last option on that order ran out on December 31, 2025, and DFAS Columbus has been buying time on it ever since, fifteen months of it so far.
The Air Force order did the same thing. And the two orders that just replaced them, announced this week, are built the same way.
Three Quotes, $1.86 Billion
Thursday's board carried two awards out of the Defense Finance and Accounting Service's Contract Services Directorate in Columbus, both labor-hour, both to Ernst & Young:
- HQ042327FE001, maximum value $455,430,043, for the Navy General Fund, Marine Corps General Fund and Department of Navy Working Capital Fund audits for fiscal 2027 through 2031. One-year base, four one-year options, completion December 31, 2031. The government received one quote.
- HQ0423-27-F-E004, maximum value $413,954,469, for the Air Force general fund and working capital fund statements. Twelve-month base, four one-year options. One quote.
Twenty-eight days before that, on the September 10 board, the same office awarded Ernst & Young HQ042326FE061 at a maximum of $989,996,050 for the agency-wide consolidated statements, fiscal 2027 through 2031, completion March 31, 2032. One quote there too.
So the whole fiscal 2027 generation of the Pentagon's financial statement audit book went to one firm in four weeks, for $1,859,380,562, on a grand total of three quotes.
We walked the structural reason a schedule order like this draws a single bid back in September, and it has not changed: FAR 8.404(a) deems a Federal Supply Schedule order to be full and open competition and tells the ordering activity it "shall not seek competition outside of the Federal Supply Schedules or synopsize the requirement." None of this money ever touched SAM.gov. A search of DFAS notices this morning returns snow removal, propane and a CCTV maintenance contract.
What is new is what the award paperwork says about time.
The rest of this brief is for subscribers.
The specific solicitations, dockets, and dates to act on sit past this line.
$50 a month, or $500 a year.
Already a subscriber? Sign in